nyconstage.org

reviews

Home

Off-Off Broadway

Off-Broadway

Broadway

Theatre Companies

Dance Companies

Music Organizations

Jazz Venues

Acting Schools

Comedy Troupes

Resources

Press & Publicity

Reviews - Wycks

Reviews - VanLoan

NYC Photos

Radio Stations

Festivals

List your show

 

Approx. 284 reviews 
#
10 Million Miles
33 to Nothing
1001 Beds
A
Abigail's Party
Absurd Person Singular
Acts of Mercy
Adrift in Macao
Alfred Hitchcock's The 39 Steps
All That I Will Ever Be
All This Intimacy
American Sligo
A Midsummer's Night Dream
A Moon for the Misbegotten
A New Television Arrives, Finally
An Oak Tree
An Octopus Love Story
A Soldier's Play
A Spanish Play
A Streetcar Named Desire
Asylum: The Strange Case of Mary Lincoln
A Touch of the Poet
A Very Merry Unauthorized Children’s Scientology Pageant
Arabian Night
B
Badge
Barefoot in the Park
Based on a Totally True Story
Bash'd: A Gay Rock Opera
Beau Brummell
Beckett Shorts
Beowulf
Beyond Glory
Bhutan
Bill W. and Dr. Bob
Birdie Blue
bombs in your mouth
Bouffon Glass Menajoree
Broken Hands
Butley
C
Cagelove
Cat on a Hot Tin Roof
Celebration and The Room
Celia
Christine Jorgensen Reveals
Colder Than Here
Columbinus
Crave
Confessions of a Mormon Boy
Crawl, Fade to White
Creation: A Clown Show
Crestfall
Crimes of the Heart
Cul-de-sac
Curtains
Cyrano
D
Dark Matters
Deep Trance Behaviour in Potato  Land
Defender of the Faith
Defiance
Devil Land (Summer Play Festival 2007)
Dirt
Disconnect
Dog Sees God
Do Not Do This Ever Again
Doubt
E
Edge
Edward Scissorhands
Edward the Second
Eh Joe
Elliot, A Soldier's Fugue
Elephant Girls
Elvis People
Entertaining Mr. Sloane
Everythings Turning Into Beautiful
Evil Dead: The Musical
F
Fabulous Divas of Broadway
Fahrenheit 451
Fatal Attraction
Faust in Love
Faust Part One & Two
Festen
Fragment
Frank's Home
Fran's Bed
From Up Here
Fringe Festival 2006 Roundup
Future Me
G
Gaslight
Give 'Em Hell Harry!
Glengarry Glen Ross
God's Ear
Good Heif
Grey Gardens
Guardians
Gutenberg! The Musical!
H
Hamlet
Happy End
Have You Seen Steve Steven
Heartbreak House
Hecuba
Hedda Gabler
Heistman
Hell House
Home
Howard Katz
Huck and Holden
I
Ice Factory 2008 (3 reviews)
I Coulda Been a Kennedy
In a Dark, Dark House
It Goes Without Saying
In the Bar of a Tokyo Hotel
Is He Dead?
Ivanov
I Used to Write on Walls
J
Jamaica Farewell
Jeremiah
K
KAOS
L
Landscape of the Body
Lennon
Lenny Bruce...in His own Words
Les Miserables
Little Willy
Looking Up
Los Big Names
Love, Punky
LoveMusik
Lower Ninth (Summer Play Festival 2007)
Lustre
M
Major Bang
Make Me A Song
Manic Flight Reaction
Man-Made
Manuscript
Masked
Measure for Measure
Mrs. Warrens Profession
Missa Solemnis or the Play about Henry
Miss Julie
Miss Witherspoon
Mother Courage
Mr. Marmalade
Much Ado About Nothing
N
Nefes
Next to Normal
New York Musical Theater Festival 2006 Roundup 1
New York Musical Theater Festival 2006 Roundup 2
Nixon's Nixon
No Child
No End of Blame
No Great Society
Nora
Not a Genuine Black Man
Nothing
November
O
Oblivious to Everyone
Oedipus at Palm Springs
On a Darkling Plain
P
Peer Gynt
Pen
Penetrator
Perfect Harmony
Philadelphia, Here I Come!
Pig Farm
Potomac Theater Project
Prelude to a Kiss
Privilege
Prometheus Bound
Q
R
Rabbit Hole
Rag and Bone
Red Bastard
Red Light Winter
Regrets Only
Richard III
Richard Cory
Ring of Fire
Romeo and Juliet
Room Service
Rope
Ryuji Sawa: The Return
S
Sa Ka La
Save the World
Scenes from an Execution
Scituate
Seascape
Shaw Sings!
She Stoops to Conquer
Shining City
Show People
Sides: the Fear is real
Small Craft Warnings
Soldiers Wife
Some Men
Somewhere in the Pacific
Sore Throats
Souvenir
Spamalot
Spirit
Spring Awakening (Broadway)
Stay
Stretch (a fantasia)
Striking 12
Strom Thurmond is not a Racist & Cleansed
Stuff Happens
Suburbia
Suddenly Last Summer
Surface to Air
Susan and God
Sweeney Todd
T
Tea and Sympathy
The Apple Tree
The Beebo Brinker Chronicles
The Blue Martini
The Butcher of Baraboo
The Caine Mutiny Court Martial
The Caucasian Chalk Circle
The Coast of Utopia (trilogy)
The Conversation
The Country Girl
The Country Wife
The Dear Boy
The Devil's Disciple
The Emperor Jones
The End of Reality
The Field
The Fifth Column
The Great American Trailer Park Musical
The Honor and Glory of Whaling
The Intelligent Design of Jenny Chow
The/King/Operetta
The Ladies of the Corridor
The Lieutenant of Inishmore
The Light in the Piazza
The Little Dog Laughed
The Little Flower of East Orange
The Madras House
The Maids
The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat
The Milliner
The Other Side
The Pain and the Itch
The Pajama Game
The Pavilion
The Possibilities
The Potomac Theater Project
The Power of Darkness
The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie
The Puppetmaster of Lodz
The Receptionist
The Revenger's Tragedy
The Ritz
The Scene
The Sea
The Seagull in the Hamptons
The Second Tosca
The Seven
The Tempest
The Three Penny Opera
The Trip to Bountiful
The Trojan Women
The Turn of the Screw
The Vertical Hour
The Water's Edge
The Wedding Singer
The Woman in White
Things We Want
Thom Pain (based on nothing)
Thrill Me
Thurgood
Tings Dey Happen
[title of show]
Toys in the Attic
Transit (Midtown International Theater Festival)
Trouble in Paradise
U
Uncle
V
Vice Girl Confidential
Victory at the Dirt Palace
Vita and Virginia
W
Wake Up Mr. Sleepy!
Walking Down Broadway
War
Well
Wigout!
X
Y
You Belong To Me: The Fifth Installment of the Death of Nations Project
You Can Go Now
Z
Zomboid
 

 

 

Review
Bill W. and Dr. Bob
New World Stages
March 8, 2007
VanLoan
vanloan@nyconstage.org

 

 

Because alcoholic (and drug) rehabilitation has gotten so upscale and 'trendy' (what with a stream of celebrities getting press attention at every step of the way), it is easy to forget there was a time when no discernable help was available. In the early thirties, Bill Wilson, a successful New York stockbroker was headed to hell in a hand basket. His alcoholic tendencies had become full-blown with the stock market crash. His wife, Lois was at her wits end with putting up with his benders. Meanwhile in Ohio, Dr. Bob Smith has been a life-long closet drinker despite his fame as a successful surgeon (although his "shaky scalpel" is well known in the area). His wife, Anne has basically turned to religion for solace. How these two dissimilar men meet and form the association which has helped millions of drunks, Alcoholics Anonymous, is the story of this play.

Conceivably, the element which most united the two men is their mutual distrust of organized religion and the power of God to help human frailty. This may have had something to do the temperaments of the men. Bill was basically self-absorbed and has an ego "the size of the Chrysler Building" as Bob once complains. Bob, himself, is solid Vermont stock and is stubborn as the day is long. He even resists the efforts of the Oxford Group, a pre-AA religious organization in helping him stay sober. It is through a series of accidents that the two men discover the power of one drunk helping another is the true secret of a sober life. Or as Bob puts it near the end of the play "Let's not louse this thing up - let's keep it simple".

Keeping it simple also seems to be the motto of the production. The set of shifting panels (Anita Fuchs) is rudimentary at best, conveying various meeting rooms and hospital wards. Co-authors Stephen Bergman (a playwright) and Janet Surrey (a psychologist) have crafted a script that sticks to the facts and despite some humorous passages feels somewhat dramatically inert. Rick Lombardo's direction is equally unobtrusive. Robert Krakovski as Bill W. feels a little too wooden for someone in the depths of alcoholic despair but Patrick Husted is wonderfully comical as the cantankerous Dr. Bob. Marc Carver provides ample support as a variety of doctors, drunks and the newly sober. Rachel Harker as Lois and Kathleen Doyle as Anne breathe as much life as they can into characters that are one-dimensional. However, the clunky-ness of the proceedings is beside the point. While the production itself may not be dramatically satisfying, it still concerns itself with one of the biggest success stories of the twentieth century.

 

...end